Foreign Aid, Norm Diffusion, and Local Support for Gender Equality: Comparing Evidence from the World Bank and China’s Aid Projects in Africa

 

Chuanhong Zhang, Zhenqian Huang

Corresponding author: Zhenqian Huang, e-mail:zhenqianh@cau.edu.cn

Studies in Comparative International Development, Published online

 

Abstract: Does foreign aid change local attitudes toward gender equality? Drawing on a theory of norm diffusion through intervention, we contend that when donors integrate norms into aid projects, such norms can be diffused to individuals in recipient countries. The World Bank and China are two comparable donors to examine this relationship. We matched the geocoded aid projects of the two donors from AidData and Afrobarometer surveys in Africa to test our hypotheses. Our strategy is to compare respondents’ attitudes toward gender equality who were near a site where the project had been implemented at the time of the interview to those who were close to a site where the project would be started after the interview. We find that the World Bank aid increases local support for gender equality and the results differ across sectors and gender. Aid going to gender-sensitive sectors has the most significant impact on women’s attitudes toward gender equality. In contrast, Chinese aid shows no similar effects. This study sheds light on the linkage between aid and social norm change and is expected to exert implications for policymakers and development practitioners adventuring in the land of aid.

Keywords: Foreign aid; Norm difusion; Gender equality; World Bank; China;  Africa

Foreign Aid, Norm Diffusion, and Local Support for Gender Equality....pdf

Link to this article: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12116-023-09381-4